The United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, which is the same court to which Maryland’s federal cases are appealed, affirmed a case over the summer whereby the plantiff essentially lost at trial due to the decision not to testify.
In the case, Scott v. WATSONTOWN TRUCKING CO. INC., Ct. App. 4th Cir. (2013), the court recants a somewhat unusual series of events regarding trial strategy and anticipation regarding testimony.
The lawsuit arose out of a collision whereby a truck driver employed by the Watsontown Trucking Company struck a motorcyclist with his tractor trailer while he was making a left turn. The motorcyclist suffered personal injuries as a result, and he filed suit in federal court, alleging negligence. According to the overview in the appellate case, the issue at trial came down to whether the truck driver had a green light when he made the turn, and if not, whether the motorcyclist was contributorily negligent.